Blackmoor wrote:I collect it all, 1st ed, 2nd ed, 3.?? There is ,lots of good about every edition IMHO
FormCritic wrote:Goodman's Dungeon Crawl Classics are 3.0 and 3.5 edition.I doubt most here would describe their products as crap.
FormCritic wrote:Also, I think that everyone here is probably aware of this, but vitually every product put out by any publisher is an attempt to "cash in" on something. Cashing in is the whole point of business. The only difference between money grabs is that some of them are smart business and some of them are bad business decisions.
MrFilthyIke wrote:Ah, poor KingofPain89, you fail to see among these boards, like at Dragonsfoot, if it's not Scottish...I mean 1E, it's automatically crap.Arguing anything other that praise on 1e on 1e/grognard boards is like debating the benefits of Western civilization to an Islamic Fundamentalist.It will only end in flames/tears/bitching/etc.
DungeonDelver wrote:Yeah that's nice dude. Hey, they don't like 3e so they're a bunch of suicide bombers and taliban.
Blackmoor wrote:The Acaeum is a collectors site!! We talk about all sorts of related gaming stuff with regards to D&D. It is not a 1st ed site. If it was we would never talk about woodies, DCC, Judges guild, planescpe........That is why I started this thread! To make collectors aware of this new release!
killjoy32 wrote:in all fairness tho, quite a few rares arent 1EAl
killjoy32 wrote:just a few:chainmail, character archaic, various character sheets, dwarven glory, PotVQ, most wee warriors stuff, all the OD&D sets, woodgrainsi'd say that makes a fair argument Al
darkseraphim wrote:I belabor you all about the head with your own schismatic quibbles.Save vs. Death Ray or take 1 hp of damage!