Plaag wrote:
Got to love the internet, cause I now know what that means

ShaneG.

lol

hey did you get an e-mail i sent a little earlier?

Al

Plaag wrote:
Aye, now I can make sure you don't forget about Tegel those days

((oh and everyone else check the previous page for the On Topic news I posted ))

ShaneG.

oops yes sorry about that. IMPORTANT TEGEL NEWS at the start of the topic before Al hijacked it as normal.

Al

killjoy32 wrote:i still go back to my original point with regards to all this.

JG being what they were back in the day, i am still very convinced that a lot of the items were mis-matched anyway and cant believe for one second that everything was so well structured, because there was no chance it could have been!

Al

Yeah I know, especially later on when it was others doing all the shipping, etc..even Bob would discover inventory was wrong. (CSWE comes to mind)

Though there has to be a sequence, Judges Guild didn't print all the maps for instance at once on different paper (I know this cause I was at the discussion meeting at last years GenCon - may have to look at those notes again for other stuff). So sure orders after the fact may have a different 'printing' component, but there must be a 'majority' if you will that are more uniform. I can only assume somethings on the site as I didn't buy everything in SW or Installment Envelopes.
The human factor (talking Judges Guild employees since items were in SW) has messed up various products, I've got a few of them, what with a map added here, extra this or that. Tac cards are a jumble when you look at the 1st print, no set has matched (but I'm keeping track ).
My only thing regarding Tegel though is the blank coversheet, I mean I can place the others, but that one is the oddity.

It maybe something that needs to be really discussed if prices are going to be put on the site, because I don't want to be the reason for someone loosing out on money because their set isn't 100% like what the site says. Course somethings people could care less about as long as its got all of its components.

ShaneG.

FormCritic wrote:What do you think of the price?  How did I do?

That's about what I paid for mine.  However, I don't have the little insert card as shown in the picture.  Let us know what that is all about.

I think $10-$15 is bout right for this book.  The Gamescience edition with the white cover is worth a bit more maybe $25-$30.  Are the Gamescience versions covered on JG subweb?

http://www.acaeum.com/jg/OC-GameScienceTegelManor.html

Interesting, but you either you forgot to mention or didn't know that the Gamescience version of Tegel Manor as written is incomplete.  It does not contain all of the material in the original version published by Judges Guild as Gamescience was not provided with an original copy of the module, only an apparently incomplete photocopy from Bob Bledsaw's personal collection.  So when it came time to update the module ... oopsie.

http://www.acaeum.com/jg/JudgesGuildOtherCompanies.html

They printed the maps with black ink on white paper to be easier to read. But yeah it has to be simply a photocopy of the map and not redrawn. (Maybe at some point I'll try and see if I can tell what printing this was photocopied from.)

ShaneG.

Melan wrote:Could you mention where these gaps are found? I have read both versions extensively, and didn't find them (except that GS took some creative liberties with things I wouldn't have - like the Tsathoggus cultists).

I don't remember the exact sections that are missing or otherwise skewed ... just that there were some discrepancies when it came time for Necro to do the 3.5 version, so they wound up having to use both and reconcile the differences.  That's one of the reasons the new release has been taking so long.

[W]hen it came time for Necro to do the 3.5 version, so they wound up having to use both and reconcile the differences.

Why would anyone bother to use the GameScience revision in making the conversion to 3.5?  You seem more than a little vague in your assertions.