Hum..you may have the 3rd printing book (will have to see if the booty list is on the cover page and not actually in the book).

ShaneG.

tdewey10 wrote:
Ah. I forgot that the 3rd ed had a cover page.  Did they all have the index error?

Yep..just checked and seems I may start the close examination with this product now that I have it out

Index on both does not list pg 47
2nd print has Booty List on pg 47
3rd print has Booty List on cover sheet

Good catch on that error.

ShaneG.

Okay curious how I should present differences for various printings. Here is what I have cobbled together for Magic Realm:

Author: Mark Holmer
Editor: Penny Gooding
Artist(s): Paul Jaquays
Interior Art only in 2nd and later printings: Kevin Siembieda, Paul Jaquays

1st Print

Oddities
Book 1 Cover: Has same image as Wilderlands of the Fantastic Reaches

Book 2 Cover: Is product number listed on this cover for when sold as set (and image changed to not confuse with Wilderlands of the Fantastic Reaches)?

Book Covers: states ‘Designed & Approved For Use Especially With' Dungeons & Dragons. Why is price listed as $8.50 on both covers?

2nd Print

Oddities
Pg 3: No page 47 listed in Index
Various Pages: Still has broken characters throughout as if the same typeset was used as the previous printing, though not in all instances (Book 2 seems better then this printing)

Differences with previous printing
Book Cover: Shares the same image as Book 2, states ‘Approved For Use With' Dungeons & Dragons

Contents:
Now 48 pages and one book
Pg 16: Designer's Notes added (previously printed in Journal 14)
Pg 40: Wilderlands map added and lists 14 numbered rectangular areas

3rd Print

Oddities
Pg 3: No page 47 listed in Index, Booty List still stated as on page 48 (Is actually Treasure vault and on back of cover sheet)
Various Pages: Still has broken characters throughout as before

Differences with previous printing
Cover Sheet: matches book cover except for being in color, author's name not shown, states ‘Created For and Approved For Use With' Dungeons & Dragons, Has product list on the back

Book Cover: Now has Judges Shield Logo, Lists contents above picture, Author's name appears in upper right of picture, Product Number and Price are in a small box in lower right, states "Official Campaign Approved For' Dungeons & Dragons

Contents:
Pg 3: Copyright 1980, Address and All rights reserved paragraph
Pg 40: Wilderlands map changes to the full 18 numbered and titled rectangles, page is also not numbered
Pg 47: Titled ‘Notes' with lines narrower then previous two pages and filling up more of the page

Should I list pages of art that was added in 2nd+ printings along with the other pages (some listed above)? Should I state where tables have been moved (replaced by art, but presented after other text now in 2nd+ printings)?
Different format compared to the one above?

ShaneG.

Ok, back to those JGJs...


What is the general price for I, J, L, Z and 22?

Yeah #22 is a combo with Dungeoneer #19

ShaneG.

jrients wrote:Howdy all!  Longtime JG fan, first time poster.  This looks like a general Q&A thread, so hopefully I'm asking this in the right place.

The Campaign Hexagon System is listed as having some charts for generating random terrain.  Do those charts appear in any other products?

Welcome!

And no I don't think they do or maybe not in the extent that they are in the Campaign Hexagon System.

ShaneG.

ddt58 wrote:My Installment M probably came with the Monstrous Compendium.  I am guessing since everything I have sat in a box for years and they different installments were all stored together, so I have been reconstructing what came with what from this site.  Unfortunately, I did not keep envelopes, but it looks like I am only missing a couple of the single pages that later became the Ready Ref sheets.

Does anyone know if JG's subscriber records were destroyed?  I think I started subscribing around Installment L, but I am not sure.  It might help reconstructing what I got and when.

A review of Journal L (back page) has the following statement:
"Along with our previously published ready-ref charts, there will be a 'Monster Compendium' listing all of the D&D monsters published so far with all of their specs in a tight listing.  This Monster Compendium will be in your next installment, also."

So the MC is supposed to be with Installment M.  I'm going to go out on a rather thick limb and guess that it didn't make it into some run of the installment.  Much like only the first run of Installment L had the Wizard's Guide.

tdewey10 wrote:
A review of Journal L (back page) has the following statement:
"Along with our previously published ready-ref charts, there will be a 'Monster Compendium' listing all of the D&D monsters published so far with all of their specs in a tight listing.  This Monster Compendium will be in your next installment, also."

So the MC is supposed to be with Installment M.  I'm going to go out on a rather thick limb and guess that it didn't make it into some run of the installment.  Much like only the first run of Installment L had the Wizard's Guide.

Yeah sadly with few having saved the mailed envelopes its hard to know.

ShaneG.

tdewey10 wrote:Plaag,

How was the Tegel first printing with the flycover sans booty list determined to be the fourth release?  I was looking for an early discussion on it but couldn't find it.

I believe this: Tegel Manor • Page 3 • Judges Guild •  The Acaeum

Would have to check..think maybe this should have been the later printed book (orange, no Ende), but if you have one with the earlier one then that helps.

ShaneG.