killjoy32 wrote:well i have 4 instalment Ms here that i havent sold you because of this issue. i have bought them from all manner of sources, one a collector too and not one had the sheet in....just seems a little coincidental to me and WOULD fit with whats been said above...anyway i am always guided by the general consensus so....Al
Rakeesh sah Tarna wrote:-- old posts Modron (Q/A)
Plaag wrote:Well, I'll say that I have an Installment M with this..which I bought from TimK..it has the Booklet M with broken text seen here: Modron DifferencesJournal M, Two maps, Journal M, Monster sheet and envelope.Journal M, unnumbered page 7, Tips from the tower says this Monster sheet is included, which is also included on the Judges Shield.Booty List #32 has the RR sheet with Booklet M, #34 has Installment as item #s 31-33What Booklet M does everyone have?ShaneG.
tdewey10 wrote:The one being auctioned is the left with the vertical printing issue. AFAIK, out of 6 Installment M's (mine, killx4 and yours) only yours has the monster sheet. Which seems pretty flipping low. Not impossible of course -- but seems improbable.
Plaag wrote:Now I could think of reasons why some maybe throw the RR sheet out if they had the same info on the card stock Judges Shield or acquired the TSR Monster & Treasure Assortments...Judges Guild was the first to compile the list of monsters, along with having a shield.ShaneG.
tdewey10 wrote:I find it hard to believe that this happened in every case but one.
Plaag wrote:Only one case states having Journal M: Ian's copy at the time..so if all of these were Installment M's then they seem to have lost the Journal M.This is basically where I'm standing at the moment on this..It is not an Installment without the Journal. (Yeah envelopes get tossed, so to have it is a bonus, but to claim booklet and maps is Installment, sorry you have to come up with something more definitive.)ShaneG.
killjoy32 wrote:Shanei have Ian's instalment M. this also came from the Burntwire Bros before that, so it has a good collecting pedigree. BUT that doesnt have the monster sheet dude...thats why i have always been so insistent that it may not have always been put in etc...Al
Plaag wrote:I still stand by its not an Installment without Journal, so if they didn't come together, it can't be argued.ShaneG.
tdewey10 wrote:Absolutely, my bad for misusing the term.
killjoy32 wrote:umm no i have three instalments and one "modron"Al