FormCritic wrote: (Also, the quality of the artwork inside the one example I own is childish...worse than 2nd Edition AD&D artwork. It makes 2nd Edition stuff look good by comparison.)
misterspock wrote:Which art did you hate the most?
TheMilford wrote:Especially the stuff that looked like it should have been airbrushed on the back of a jean jacket or a conversion van... which was most of it.
misterspock wrote:I thought there was some really good stuff in 2nd ed...granted not all of it was. But I can think of a number of modules and books that were really well done. I know TSR was re-using a fair amount into other later-issued adventures which kind of bugged me. Which art did you hate the most?
FormCritic wrote:The Black Blade publishing effort is pretty cool.We need to go there and buy their stuff.I am saddened by the quality of the latest DCC stuff for 4th edition.
goodmangames wrote:It's all native B/W. You're welcome to dislike it, just dislike it for the right reasons, and downsampling isn't one of them.
FormCritic wrote: So, I've been back here 15 minutes and I've already dissed and offended two publisher guys. My personal Jerk-O-Meter must be pegged to the max at the moment. The product I am talking about is Mists of Madness. The fellow on the cover would fit nicely in one of the 2nd Edition core books. He appears to be struggling to see out of his ludicrous helmet. The cover art also appears in two places inside the module, slugged into black and white. The whole picture is only visible on page 20. The other interior art, with the exception of page 9, either isn't very good or did not reproduce well. The maps look like scenes from Perry Mason, filmed at night.OK - I'm commenting on a $2 module. So, I do admit the jerk factor here.Thing is...I really like the Dungeon Crawl Classics, which is why I'm inclined to blather about them like a mean drunk.This module was my introduction to the 4th Edition product line.
FormCritic wrote: So, I've been back here 15 minutes and I've already dissed and offended two publisher guys. My personal Jerk-O-Meter must be pegged to the max at the moment.
Badmike wrote:I'm a map guy. I'll buy a product just becaus the map looks cool.
Kingofpain89 wrote:Pretty much the main reason I own any Judges Guild product. One look at those Wilderlands maps and I was hooked.
FormCritic wrote:I am referring specifically to three prominent features of 2nd Edition art
bbarsh wrote:Welcome back Mark
Badmike wrote:Maybe the funky helmets are a tribute to Lord Otus?