Thork N Hammer, Esquire wrote:off of eBay--

Verbosh(last printing)
Caverns of Thracia(2nd or 3rd I think)
Under the Storm Giant's Castle


for $40 +$11.35 shipping...

that averages to about $17 each.
Assuming the condition of each is Fair+ to Good, did I do okay?

Ouch. I'd say that's a bit high, especially in lower-end condition, but I'm no expert on JG.

EDIT: There's some Judges Guild info here, including some valuations. Not sure if they're current:

http://www.acaeum.com/jg/IndexbyTitle.html

I also think you paid too much for them.
Not terribly so, but certainly more than I would have paid, given the low end condition they are in.
Especially the big money item (Thrashia) as it looks the worst of the group.

Thracia usually commands more than $30 for nice copies, but that one is barely fair if that.

Under the Storm Giants Castle seems to sell at around $15 for a nice copy.

Verbosh should sell for around $5 for a very nice copy.

So not rediculous, but you could have easily done better.
In fact I would have sold you the same books in MUCH better condition for the same price if asked.
I have extra copies of all of those and more...

Gnat the Beggar wrote:  ....I would have sold you the same books in MUCH better condition for the same price if asked.
I have extra copies of all of those and more...

NOW you tell me!

Invincible Overlord wrote:I always get the feeling that when I'm bidding on an item, someone's always trying to bid me up...

... until I don't need the item(s) anymore, then they seem to sell for real cheap...

So you paid a few bucks extra... no big deal...

You and I MUST be bidding on and fighting for all the same stuff.