I actually monitered it until the end and although I was bit surprised that it went for $20.00 I just chalked it up to some
newbie bidding. I guess my question is what about this is different? Isn't it possible that it is just a 6th printing with the last 2 pages removed?
Sure it's possible. The 6th and 7th printings have perforated pages. I can't see any stubs in my copies; the remainder of a perforated page that was removed. But it would be hard to say for a certainty that they weren't there. I am supposing that the 6th and 7th prints only had 236 pages and the 237,238 reference page wasn't included.
Being the print fiend for
PHB,
MM,
DMG that I am, I now heartily regret not bidding more for that copy.
Incidentally, that is only the 2nd time that I have seen an e-Bay auction end in a tie. I wonder what the later bidder is thinking. I'll pay $20 for it, but I'll be damned if I'll pay 20.50.