deimos3428 wrote:But if you can't tell a "saucy tart" from a "wanton wench", what's the point in playing?
deimos3428 wrote:I broke down and voted for the DMG, as it best represents that which is 1E. Why? Take a look at page 192, gentlemen. Any book detailed enough to provide a subtable for the type of harlot you might encounter has got to be the clear winner. You definitely won't find this sort of thing in later editions. But if you can't tell a "saucy tart" from a "wanton wench", what's the point in playing?
Artur wrote:I think I'd vote for the Fiend Folio as the worst of the 1E manuals.
flying_purple_monkfish wrote:Hmmm, i'm not sure... I'm rather partial to Skills and Powers...I also have a bit of a soft spot for the arms and equipment guide.
Blackmoor wrote:DMG best!!UA worst
Keith the Thief wrote:Thoughts?
g026r wrote:It's not statistically significant until the book I voted for comes in first!
Keith the Thief wrote:So, after re-thinking the math, I think 56 votes is probably enough to declare the DMG the winner in this poll.Thoughts?
Keith the Thief wrote:In the "Favorite OD&D Supplement" poll, I had guessed that 90 votes would be needed for a statistically significant sampling based on total membership of The Acaeum. However, there are probably a couple of hundred registered members who are not active and probably another couple of hundred who don't give a rat's arse.So, after re-thinking the math, I think 56 votes is probably enough to declare the DMG the winner in this poll.Thoughts?Thanks,Keith