Keith the Thief wrote:From this list -- setting sentiment aside -- I would choose:White Plume MountainTomb of HorrorsG1G2G3The Village of HommletI bought the Caverns of Thracia last year and read it for the first time. It seemed solid enough from what I recall.Once I own a copy of A4 again (In the Dungeons of the Slavelords), I'd like to re-assess it against my own criteria.
Badmike wrote:Obviously we are not going to agree in the slightest on this issue, no matter the opinions expressed. I'm going to go forward with "Some modules are definitely better written than others" while you'll stand by "Every module is the best module ever made in someone's mind and we should respect that preference." Neither is right or wrong, to ourselves, but at this point there IS no point in commenting on our positions to each other any further.... Mike B.
deimos3428 wrote:Well..this thread got stupid in a hurry. Sorry, that's an opinion, not a fact.
Badmike wrote:if Ed Greenwood was independently publishing "Undermountain: The Lowest Levels" and it was exactly the dimensions of the Castle Whiterock set, I would be there the first day to buy one. I guess I'm just an old schooler at heart... Mike B.
bombadil wrote:I'd be interested in hearing how others of the older generation here first heard about the G-series. G1 is the only adventure I can think of that generated a near-mythos among the gamers I hung out with. Its reputation for good battle and great treasure swept through gzmers in our school the way the storyline of the adventure swept through the characters embedded in it.
Deadlord39 wrote:We stole the G series, along with the D series and Q1. Well, my brother did, actually. He was a phenomenal shoplifter. We couldn't come close to affording more than one module at best.
bombadil wrote:Did anyone here play the G-series at the tourney or con where they were introduced? I can't remember which convention it was...
bombadil wrote:Oooooo, sounds like a good read! Do you remember which one it was?