bbarsh wrote:22 if I counted right. I don't have any of the 3e or 2e(??) stuff on the list. Don't want it either. I do have real problem with that list. I don't think compilation adventures should count. Forget the fact that several of those listed can't possibly ranked correctly. Then we have X2? ToEE? WG4? No freaking way they are even in my top 30. And how in the hell does I6 make #2. It was/is cool, but no way it is second best all time.
Xaxaxe wrote:Okay, I've always wanted to try a poll, and this seems like a decent enough excuse ...The November 2004 issue of Dungeon ran an article entitled "The 30 Greatest D&D Adventures of All Time." The list is below; my question to you: at this exact moment in time, how many of these do you own? Feel free to add comments, too.The list (leaving out some "the's" and "of's" to speed up typing time):30. Ghost Tower of Inverness29. Assassin's Knot28. Lost City27. Sinister Secret of Saltmarsh26. City of Skulls25. Dragons of Despair24. City of the Spider Queen (3e)23. Forgotten Temple of Tharizdun22. Lost Caverns of Tsoj.21. Dark Tower (JG)20. Scourge of the Slave Lords19. Against the Cult / Reptile God18. Hidden Shrine of Tam.17. Ruins of Undermountain16. Isle of Dread15. Castle Amber14. Dead Gods13. Dwellers / Forbidden City12. Forge of Fury (3e)11. Gates of Firestorm Peak10. Return to the Tomb of Horrors9. White Plume Mountain8. Return / ToEE (3e)7. Keep on the Borderlands6. Desert of Desolation5. Expedition / Barrier Peaks4. Temple of EE3. Tomb of Horrors2. Ravenloft1. Queen of the Spiders]
Xaxaxe wrote:Okay, I've always wanted to try a poll, and this seems like a decent enough excuse ...The November 2004 issue of Dungeon ran an article entitled "The 30 Greatest D&D Adventures of All Time." The list is below; my question to you: at this exact moment in time, how many of these do you own? Feel free to add comments, too.The list (leaving out some "the's" and "of's" to speed up typing time):24. City of the Spider Queen (3e)+++++[side note: Erik, if you're reading this, this is exactly the sort of article that would get me to subscribe; if I could count on six such entertaining articles every year, I'd sign up right now. As it is, I've no use at all for the current "here's another three D&D 3.528b4 adventures" format.]