Blackmoor wrote:deimos3428 wrote:Question on that -- if I steal a writer's notes before it's finished, is it still copyrighted? (Ok, sure, it's outright theft to steal the physical paper, let's skip that bit for now.) When is something officially and automatically "copyrighted" -- after each character is written? After each word? When the pen starts to move? When the whole thing is finished and the author puts the pen down? When he picks the pen up to write? Assume similar questions for digital media. I don't know the answers, but someone must have thought this through by now. It seems to me copyright has to include something essentially original, as well, and not all photos/digital images are worthy works of art, by a long shot. I think taking someone else's picture for auction purposes is wrong, but not for the same reason you do -- because it cannot represent the item being sold. The number of times I've seen the Acaeum 1st print MM image up is probably beyond counting -- and most of them are 5ths on later interrogation.To deep for me!!
deimos3428 wrote:Question on that -- if I steal a writer's notes before it's finished, is it still copyrighted? (Ok, sure, it's outright theft to steal the physical paper, let's skip that bit for now.) When is something officially and automatically "copyrighted" -- after each character is written? After each word? When the pen starts to move? When the whole thing is finished and the author puts the pen down? When he picks the pen up to write? Assume similar questions for digital media. I don't know the answers, but someone must have thought this through by now. It seems to me copyright has to include something essentially original, as well, and not all photos/digital images are worthy works of art, by a long shot. I think taking someone else's picture for auction purposes is wrong, but not for the same reason you do -- because it cannot represent the item being sold. The number of times I've seen the Acaeum 1st print MM image up is probably beyond counting -- and most of them are 5ths on later interrogation.
Achizar wrote:Also, is it just me or does he seem to think that when you cut out part of a page, it doesn't affect the page's other side?
bclarkie wrote:This guy is Really excited about this auction:Dungeons Dragons The Keep on the Borderlands Module | eBayYou have got to love the "MAY THE BIDDING WARS RAGE ON!!" comment.
seeyouinescrow wrote:This one is just too funny...even funnier that it has a bid! D.D. Crow Super RARE | eBay
GraysonAC wrote:seeyouinescrow wrote:This one is just too funny...even funnier that it has a bid!Super Rare 1981 TSR Catalog Shows AD D Chainmail etc | eBayWhat's funny about that one?I'd guess that catalogs are pretty rare, given how often they just get tossed into the trash I sell a similar item (the "candid letter" that was put out by WotC marketing when they bought TSR), and I've sold a bunch of 'em: Conan TSR: Role Playing Games | eBay
seeyouinescrow wrote:This one is just too funny...even funnier that it has a bid!Super Rare 1981 TSR Catalog Shows AD D Chainmail etc | eBay
seeyouinescrow wrote:GraysonAC wrote:What's funny about that one?I'd guess that catalogs are pretty rare, given how often they just get tossed into the trash I sell a similar item (the "candid letter" that was put out by WotC marketing when they bought TSR), and I've sold a bunch of 'em:WoTC Takes Over TSR Flyer from TSR Rare | eBayI guess it's just me...to me the item your selling is significantly more rare. Actually, I've got about 20-25 of those 1981 catalogs piled up w/ all my B2's & X1's...I just keep them around to put together accurate Basic/Expert Sets with original paperwork, RPGA membership forms, etc. Maybe I should start selling them individually!
GraysonAC wrote:What's funny about that one?I'd guess that catalogs are pretty rare, given how often they just get tossed into the trash I sell a similar item (the "candid letter" that was put out by WotC marketing when they bought TSR), and I've sold a bunch of 'em:WoTC Takes Over TSR Flyer from TSR Rare | eBay
Badmike wrote:seeyouinescrow wrote:I guess it's just me...to me the item your selling is significantly more rare. Actually, I've got about 20-25 of those 1981 catalogs piled up w/ all my B2's & X1's...I just keep them around to put together accurate Basic/Expert Sets with original paperwork, RPGA membership forms, etc. Maybe I should start selling them individually! Over the years I've sold a bunch of these in the $5 range....remember, the casual collector either doesn't have access to these or has never seen one before (since they came out 25 or so years ago...). You should put a price on those catalogs and put them up for bid, you might be surprised!Mike B.
seeyouinescrow wrote:I guess it's just me...to me the item your selling is significantly more rare. Actually, I've got about 20-25 of those 1981 catalogs piled up w/ all my B2's & X1's...I just keep them around to put together accurate Basic/Expert Sets with original paperwork, RPGA membership forms, etc. Maybe I should start selling them individually!