PeterFedofsky wrote:The set was purchased years ago at an estate sale for $10!
PeterFedofsky wrote:I used to play D&D regularly (that is until 3rd edition )
PeterFedofsky wrote:so it had some sentimental value for me. Kitsch factor aside, I am not enough of a serious collector to want to hang on this. I figured that someone would get more enjoyment out of this than me.
PeterFedofsky wrote:The set was purchased years ago at an estate sale for $10! I used to play D&D regularly (that is until 3rd edition ) so it had some sentimental value for me. Kitsch factor aside, I am not enough of a serious collector to want to hang on this. I figured that someone would get more enjoyment out of this than me.Oh, btw, I will end it and relist when you are all done debating the authenticity of the set. If that is what it takes, then so be it!
PeterFedofsky wrote:Oh, btw, I will end it and relist when you are all done debating the authenticity of the set. If that is what it takes, then so be it!
draco76 wrote:I tell ya what man you got it for $10 I'll send ya a $20 for it Double your money in just one year what an investment lol!
PeterFedofsky wrote:LMAO! I knew that I should not have revealed that tidbit... I have ended the auction pending the ongoing discussion. Having been sniped a billion times on EBay, I understand how unfair it can be. I would much rather take offers from those interested parties here. It seems a fair way to get around the pains of EBay. Thanks for all of your understanding.
draco76 wrote:I'm setting my snipe at $20 who cares what ya paid for it, its all about whats its worth
harami2000 wrote:[ Image ]
PeterFedofsky wrote:Good info, David. Here's the plan. I will let you all debate the authenticity and general worth of this set. When you all can come up with a fair consensus of a BIN price, I will relist the item on EBay. The other option is that the bidding can be done here. The only fair way to bid outside of EBay would be to have a completely transparent bidding process. I would not want to have people emailing me bids and then have someone make the accusation that any party was not being honest. Thoughts? Suggestions?
Aneoth wrote:Why must Peter re-list his box set?
Aneoth wrote:I would therefore value the incomplete box set at or about the grade of Very Good to Excellent, based on the Acaeums lists. There is no way I could place a value anywhere near the top listed value shown on that list for recent sales of similar Box Sets. Those were to my knowledge ALL complete sets.So, after this long-winded script, what is my final conclusion? I am afraid that the set that you have is quite unfortunately, incomplete. And that is truly tragic. As I was perfectly willing to accept the wrath of my wife and put myself to the curb with no roof over my balding head for a First Print Woody.Tragically, your set is much like the set of Wood Grain Set Books with NO box at all, which sold on E-Bay (Along with several other rare books included in the auction) for less than $150 less than a month ago. I know, I was bidding on it just for the woody books alone. Someone here (I forget who) can attest to this as he won the auction by sniping me!No box = No box set. Only two books with a box = No box set. There you go.... my 2 coppers worth....